When Do You Hire a Brand Communications Agency?

When is the right time to hire a brand communications agency?

NOW. LIKE. RIGHT. NOW.

Only joking. Sort of.

At some point, most growing businesses hit a moment where effort no longer equals impact.

You’re posting on social media. You’ve invested in a website refresh. Maybe you’ve even worked with a PR agency or marketing agency before. On paper, you’re doing all the right things, but the brand still feels fragmented. Internally, teams aren’t aligned. Externally, the market doesn’t quite get you.

This is usually the point where founders and marketers start asking a different kind of question.

Is it time to hire an agency?

Of course, if you’ve never hired an agency before or you’ve hired the wrong one in the past, that decision can feel risky. This guide demystifies what a brand communications agency actually does, how it differs from other agencies like marketing and PR, and the real signs that the timing is right.

‍

What a brand communications agency actually does

At its simplest, brand communications is about how your brand communicates. Everywhere. To everyone.

Not just what you say on social media. Not just what’s written on your website. And definitely not just the press releases you send when you have news to share.

A brand communications agency looks at the full picture. How your brand sounds, looks, and shows up across every touchpoint, internal and external. It connects the dots between strategy, brand, marketing, and communications so your business feels clear, confident, and cohesive.

That means communicating your brand through:

• Strategy and positioning that give your business direction
• Branding that people actually understand
• Copy and content creation that aligns with your audience
• Design and visual language that supports consistently
• Marketing strategy that connects with your goals
• External communications to get your message across
• Internal communications that align teams and leadership

Often Brand Communications gets confused with PR. Unlike a PR agency that focuses on media relations, journalists, press conferences, and media coverage, or a marketing agency that concentrates on campaigns, channels, and performance, a brand communications agency works across everything that carries your message.

The work starts upstream.

Before thinking about media attention, launches, or which channel to post on next, a brand communications agency helps define:

• Who you are as a brand
• What you stand for
• Why your product or service matters
• How that story should be communicated consistently across your website, marketing, PR efforts, customer experience, and internal teams

In practice, this looks like a strategic communications framework that guides every decision. Your marketing team, sales team, leadership teams, and external partners are all working from the same playbook.

At I Am Female*, this is exactly how we work. We actively communicate brands (and we’re pretty damn good at it, too). But that means starting with purpose. Without that, you can’t define the strategy, brand, design, copy, and channel marketing that will get your business growing.

Because when the foundation is clear, everything else works harder. Campaigns land better. Media exposure feels intentional. Its a win-win situation.

‍

Brand communications vs marketing and advertising

One of the most common points of confusion for business owners is understanding where brand communications sits alongside marketing and advertising.

Here’s a simple way to think about it:

• Brand communications shape how the brand is understood
• Marketing distributes that understanding
• Advertising amplifies it at scale

Brand communications is not just about words on a page or messages in a deck. It encompasses how your brand is experienced as a whole. Strategy, narrative, design, tone, structure, and behaviour all play a role.

Marketing agencies are often execution-focused. They look at campaigns, funnels, channels, sales enablement, and performance metrics. Branding agencies typically focus on visual identity, design systems, and how a brand looks. PR agencies focus on journalists, media outlets, press conferences, and media coverage.

A brand communications agency connects all of these disciplines.

It ensures that your strategy, brand identity, design, marketing, PR, website, social media, media exposure, and internal communications are all reinforcing the same idea. Not just saying the same thing, but expressing it in ways that feel coherent and intentional to the right audience.

Without this alignment, even the best marketing agency or PR partner will struggle to deliver sustainable brand awareness or brand recognition.

‍

Types of brand communications agencies and services

Not all agencies approach brand communications in the same way.

Some sit closer to public relations and act as an extension of PR agencies. Others lean toward branding agencies with a stronger emphasis on messaging and design. The most effective brand communications agencies operate strategically across:

• Brand positioning and narrative development
• Strategic communications planning
• Content creation and messaging systems
• Media relations guidance (without being PR-only)
• Launch and new product communications
• Crisis management and crisis planning
• Internal communications and leadership alignment

The key difference is not the services listed; it’s whether the agency plays a strategic role in aligning your communications across touchpoints and being effective in doing it.

‍

When should you hire a brand communications agency?

You’re launching a new brand, product, or service

A launch is one of the clearest signs it may be the right time to bring in a brand communications agency.

Whether you’re a startup launching for the first time or an established company introducing a new product, launches require more than press releases and social media posts. They require a compelling narrative that resonates with customers, media, and potential investors.

Without a clear brand story, launches often generate short-term noise but little long-term impact.

You’re entering new markets or audiences

Expanding into new markets, whether geographic or demographic, introduces complexity. What worked before may no longer land with a new target audience.

A brand communications agency helps businesses adapt their messaging without diluting their brand, ensuring relevance while maintaining consistency across markets.

Mergers, acquisitions, or reorganisation

Periods of structural change often expose internal problems in communication.

When teams, business models, or leadership teams shift, clarity becomes critical. A unified narrative helps align the whole team internally while managing external perception across media, customers, and investors.

Your brand feels outdated

Rebrands are rarely just about design.

If your visual identity no longer reflects who you are , or if your brand perception doesn’t match your internal vision , a brand communications agency ensures that your refreshed brand identity is current for your goals, audience and market. It encompasses design systems, language, positioning, and strategic direction.

You’re preparing for a major milestone, IPO, or funding round

When investors and potential investors are paying attention, clarity matters.

Strong brand communications help businesses articulate their value, growth story, and competitive edge, not just to media outlets, but to the people making funding decisions.

‍

Signs your brand may need agency help

You have inconsistent messaging across channels and teams

If your website says one thing, your sales team says another, and your social media tells a different story again, that inconsistency erodes trust.

Brand communications agencies exist to create alignment across teams and channels.

Your brand lacks a clear brand story

If you struggle to explain what your company does , or why it matters , that’s a strong signal.

When internal teams lack clarity, customers and journalists feel it immediately.

You have difficulty explaining your value

Many business owners know they have a good idea, but can’t articulate it succinctly.

A brand communications agency helps translate complexity into clarity , without oversimplifying what makes you different.

How people perceive your brand doesn’t match your vision

If your strong brand internally doesn’t translate externally, there’s a communication gap.

That gap often shows up in media attention, customer experience, and sales conversations.

Your internal capacity is limited

Even the best in-house team reaches capacity.

A brand communications agency doesn’t replace your team , it supports team members with strategy, structure, and process during periods of growth.

How you show up across marketing channels is inconsistent

When creative, marketing, PR, and leadership teams operate in silos, fragmentation is inevitable. When your foundations are shaky, people will do their own thing. Brand communications bring everything together under one narrative to ensure you’re communicating in the best way across all touchpoints.

‍

External red flags that signal you may need agency help

Your marketing efforts aren’t giving you the results you’re looking for

If marketing activity is happening but results are stalling, the issue is often strategic, not tactical. For example, you can throw as much money as you like into social ads, but if the foundations are flawed, your ROI will stay low.

There’s confusion in the market about who you are

If customers, media, or partners misunderstand your role or value, clarity is missing.

Your competitors are overtaking you

When competitors articulate their positioning more clearly, they gain a competitive edge , even with similar products.

You’re being left behind in the market or experiencing backlash

People increasingly expect brands to echo their values and remain authentic. Strategic communications ensure you live your values and communicate in a way that evolves with the market and your audience's expectations.

‍

5 reasons to bring in an agency partner

To get a fresh, expert, outside perspective

An external agency offers objectivity, expertise and clarity. A fresh perspective can reveal blind spots that internal teams are too close to see.

To strengthen and grow your brand

Growth can happen without an agency. But if you’re looking to grow your business faster and more sustainably, the right agency will help you do that. Brand communications helps your brand grow through a scalable platform that supports marketing, sales, PR efforts, and future launches.

To engage leadership and stakeholders

When leadership teams are aligned around a shared narrative, decision-making becomes easier and faster.

To scale your marketing efforts

As businesses grow, your marketing efforts have to grow with it. If you’re struggling to juggle it in-house, an agency may be the best option to help you scale. Sometimes hiring in-house isn’t the most cost-effective, and you don’t want to fall into the trap of hiring one person who has to juggle EVERYTHING. That won’t get you the best results.

To get better ROI

When you have the right brand comms agency, your ROI will grow. Plus, sometimes hiring internally can be more costly and less effective than using an agency. It really depends on your goals and capabilities. But the reality is, the right agency will make you money, not take it away. Emphasis on the “right”.

‍

How to choose the right brand communications agency

If you’ve never hired an agency before, this is usually the part that feels the most daunting.

By this point, you’re probably clear that you need support. The harder question is how to choose an agency that actually fits your business, your people, and the work that needs doing, rather than one that just looks good on paper.

Before deciding who to work with, it helps to understand how agencies actually operate behind the scenes, not just what they say they do on their website.

How agencies actually work

Agencies tend to follow a few common models. These models shape how they collaborate with clients, how predictable the work feels, and how involved they become in your business over time.

Some common ways agencies structure their work include:

Retainer model: A fixed monthly fee for ongoing support. This creates consistency and deeper relationships, but it does require clear expectations around scope and priorities on both sides.

Project-based model: A defined piece of work with a clear start and end. This works well for launches, rebrands, or specific strategic projects, especially if you’re not ready for a long-term commitment.

Hybrid or productised models: Scoped packages or fixed-price engagements that make it easier to budget and test an agency before committing more deeply.

In reality, many strong agency partnerships blend these approaches. An agency might start with a project and evolve into a retainer, or combine ongoing strategic support with one-off execution sprints.

What matters far more than the label is whether the working style fits how you want to operate.

3 things that actually matter when hiring any agency

When you’re deciding who to work with, portfolio slides and shiny stats are only part of the picture.

What really matters is fit, and that fit shows up on multiple levels.

Brand alignment, do they get you?

This goes beyond surface-level experience.

Relevant experience can be helpful, but here’s a hot take we genuinely believe. An agency does not need deep experience in your exact sector to do great work. What they do need is a strong understanding of your industry, your audience, and the dynamics you’re operating within, paired with creative thinking about how to approach it.

In many cases, agencies with adjacent experience bring stronger ideas because they’re not constrained by industry habits or assumptions.

When you’re assessing brand alignment, ask yourself:

• Do they connect with your brand?
• Do they ask questions challenging and informed questions about the brand?
• Have they worked with similar brands or brands in adjacent industries?

The right agency should feel like an extension of your thinking. They should get the brand quickly and ask the right questions.

Working alignment, do you actually work well together?

This is the part people often underestimate.

You’re hiring people, not logos. Even the smartest strategists won’t help if the working relationship feels strained or misaligned.

Think about things like:

• Style of collaboration. Do you want a close partnership where you think together, or a team that executes independently?
• Communication rhythms. Do they favour async updates, regular calls, or structured check-ins?
• Values and energy. Do you leave conversations feeling understood and energised, or drained?

Agencies do their best work when they adapt to your rhythm, not when you’re forced to adapt to theirs.

A great agency doesn’t just align with your brand. They connect with your people, respect how you work, and make collaboration feel like added capacity rather than another thing to manage.

Capability fit, can they actually deliver what you need?

This is where practicality comes in.

Your business goals, internal capability, budget, and growth plans should all shape what kind of agency support makes sense right now.

Ask yourself:

• Do they have the skills and resources we need, not just in strategy, but across design, brand identity, digital presence, and cross-channel execution if that’s required?
• Can they work alongside our internal team in a way that makes sense, for example, leading strategy while in-house teams handle execution?
• Does their pricing model align with our stage of growth? If budgets are tight, would a freelancer or specialist be more appropriate at this stage?

The truth is that what works for one business won’t work for another. A startup may need flexible strategic scaffolding, while a more established team may want an agency to slot into a defined strategic role without duplicating internal work.

‍

Is there actually a “right” time to hire an agency?

Yes. Now. Call us.

Ok, we’re kidding. It’s actually a bit of a trick question. There is no universal right time to be hiring a brand communications agency, or any other kind of agency, for that matter. And anyone who tells you that is lying.

Every brand is different. Hiring an agency might be the perfect thing for you right now. Then again, it might not.

But one thing’s for sure…

If you’re asking whether you should hire an agency, maybe it's time for a conversation with one.

Let’s chat. We’ll help you work out whether it's the right next step. We’re not “yes” women, so we’ll always be up front about what's possible and what’s not. No obligations.

‍